People and Culture Shared Interest Group

  • 1.  Recruitment: How is volunteer leadership assessed during recruitment for middle management roles?

    Posted 28 days ago

    For people who have volunteer leadership roles on different forums or Board committees outside of their regular jobs - how is their volunteer leadership experience valued as a part of their resume especially for middle management jobs (not fresh starts)?

    Does it make a difference in the recruitment? Do hiring managers consider that valuable experience?



    ------------------------------
    Izz Ansari
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Recruitment: How is volunteer leadership assessed during recruitment for middle management roles?

    Posted 27 days ago
    Edited by Tusti Agarwal 27 days ago

    As a Fresher, this is something I incredibly am curious about. I have been volunteering in Leadership Roles throughout my academic and personal life thinking that it would help my resume stand out from other candidates and prove that I possess some additional skill set from that of others.
    But does it really makes my profile stand out? Does those fancy titles (for which I've worked hard even in my free times) really make an impact on the recruiter's mind for Management Roles and makes me a preferable candidate?

    Or do hiring managers view them differently? 



    ------------------------------
    Tusti Agarwal
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Recruitment: How is volunteer leadership assessed during recruitment for middle management roles?

    Posted 26 days ago

    Speaking from my personal experience, recruiters have never placed significant emphasis on my volunteer experience-whether I was a fresher or working at a middle management level. One reason could be that volunteer roles typically do not involve rigorous selection or evaluation based on specific skill sets and competencies. In my case, recruiters were primarily focused on assessing how proficient I was in the technical skills required for the role.


    Regards
    Kushnabh






  • 4.  RE: Recruitment: How is volunteer leadership assessed during recruitment for middle management roles?

    Posted 24 days ago

    Thanks Kushnabh for sharing your experience. I also think it can be difficult for them to verify this experience so they may not consider it reliable. Just a thought.



    ------------------------------
    Izz Ghanaa Ansari
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: Recruitment: How is volunteer leadership assessed during recruitment for middle management roles?

    Posted 25 days ago

    From my experience, the value of volunteer leadership depends less on the title itself and more on who's evaluating it.

    Some hiring managers see it as a strong signal that you're willing to invest in your own growth, lead without formal authority, and contribute to the profession beyond your day job. Others may focus almost exclusively on your direct work deliverables.

    I've found that leaders who volunteer themselves, or who prioritize continuous learning and professional development, tend to value these experiences much more. They understand that leading a committee, organizing events, speaking at conferences, or serving on a board develops skills that are directly transferable to the workplace: influencing, stakeholder management, communication, strategic thinking, and leadership.

    That said, I also think there's an important balance. Volunteer work shouldn't come at the expense of delivering in your primary role. Your day job has to come first. The volunteer experience becomes valuable because it complements strong performance at work, not because it replaces it.

    For me, volunteering has expanded my network, exposed me to perspectives outside my company, and created opportunities - like public speaking - that I likely wouldn't have had otherwise. Those experiences have made me a stronger finance professional, even though they weren't part of my formal job description.

    So while I wouldn't expect volunteer leadership alone to land someone a role, I do think it can become a meaningful differentiator when candidates have similar professional experience. It tells me the person is curious, engaged in the profession, and willing to continue growing outside the boundaries of their day-to-day responsibilities.



    ------------------------------
    Polina Nyer CMA, CSCA
    Analyst
    Newport RI
    United States
    ------------------------------



  • 6.  RE: Recruitment: How is volunteer leadership assessed during recruitment for middle management roles?

    Posted 24 days ago

    Thanks Polina, I agree that people who have been in similar roles definitely value it more. 



    ------------------------------
    Izz Ghanaa Ansari
    ------------------------------



  • 7.  RE: Recruitment: How is volunteer leadership assessed during recruitment for middle management roles?

    Posted 24 days ago

    I guess my follow-up question would be - would you bring your experience up intentionally during interviews as well, or would you rather wait for them to bring it up?



    ------------------------------
    Izz Ghanaa Ansari
    ------------------------------



  • 8.  RE: Recruitment: How is volunteer leadership assessed during recruitment for middle management roles?

    Posted 18 days ago
    Edited by Kisha Chandler 18 days ago

    I agree, Polina! Izz great post!

    While I deeply value volunteer service, I've never been fond of the word volunteer. The term often minimizes the significant personal and professional growth that comes from these experiences. I view these roles as leadership development opportunities. Whether serving on a committee, mentoring students, organizing events, or leading programs, individuals are building skills, expanding networks, and gaining practical experience that strengthens their careers. That's why I often encourage students and professionals to view these experiences not as volunteer work, but as leadership experience that should always be highlighted on a resume as such (Leadership Experience).
    I have also seen folks list these opportunities on their LinkedIn profile as jobs, this is deceiving and I do not recommend it. 



    ------------------------------
    Kisha Chandler

    ------------------------------



  • 9.  RE: Recruitment: How is volunteer leadership assessed during recruitment for middle management roles?

    Posted 24 days ago

    I have had a mixed experience about volunteer leadership being noticed by recruiters - I can speak for entry level & 3-4 years of experienced roles rather than middle management .

    Hiring managers do notice the volunteer roles & it  had made me stand out from the crowd a few times, I think a volunteer leadership role would show your commitment towards learning new skills & keeping yourself in touch with the profession. It's more interesting skills like public speaking, building & growing a community that catch the eye, which definitely would give you an edge on the visibility part, and I think visibility can open so many doors. 

    While, some hiring managers have asked me about the volunteering part of my career with utmost interest, some have never brought it up at all - so it also depends on the person hiring you & their perspective of looking at potential candidates for a role. 

    Irrespective of whether the recruiters notice it or give you an edge over the volunteer leadership skills - I think it's important - we talk about it on the resume & while giving a broad introduction, because it's worth mentioning :)



    ------------------------------
    Yukta Sharma


    Hyderabad
    India
    ------------------------------